Blog
I swapped my Apple Watch Series 10 for a Google Pixel Watch 3 — here’s what I liked and disliked
If you own an iPhone and you’re fully locked into the Apple ecosystem, then it’s hard to look past choosing the Apple Watch as your smartwatch. Whether it’s our top smartwatch pick or the number one smartwatch choice for women, it’s a tough one to beat.
There are other great smartwatches outside of the Apple Watch, including the Google Pixel Watch 3. It’s our favourite Android smartwatch and is proof that great Wear OS smartwatches exist.
So what would happen if you swapped Apple Watch for Google Pixel Watch to dish out those phone notifications, let you make payments from the wrist, or let the music play sans smartphone?
That’s exactly what we did to find out if Google’s best is a good enough alternative to the Apple Watch Series 10. Here’s what we liked and disliked as we did smartwatch swapsies.
What I liked
1. The Fitbit-powered fitness and health tracking
If there’s one area in general I think Wear OS smartwatches struggle in comparison to the Apple Watch, it’s with the native fitness and health tracking support. It’s generally good in parts, but lacks as a package. That’s where the Pixel Watch 3 differs, and that’s mainly down to the strong Fitbit integration, which essentially takes care of monitoring daily step counts, motivating you to keep moving during the day, and offers the kind of metrics and insights that are both glanceable and actually useful to pay attention to.
A few features stand out particularly on the Pixel Watch. One is sleep tracking, which Fitbit has had quite a head start on Apple, both with tracking and with the level of metrics it can offer. Apple’s sleep tracking support is pretty solid, but in contrast to what you get on the Pixel Watch, the presentation of data on and off the watch is a bit slicker.
Readiness scores are another feature that’s a win for Google over Apple. It’s a good example of a metric that’s powered by reliable tracking of heart rate and sleep. Once calibrated, these scores can offer a simple heads-up of whether you should work out or take a rest day. Currently, Apple doesn’t offer a similar readiness-type score that is a great feature for fitness newbies and more experienced fitness lovers.
2. A bit more battery life
The Google Pixel Watch 3 is hardly a battery powerhouse, especially compared to other Wear OS smartwatches like the OnePlus Watch 3 and many of Mobvoi’s dual-display-toting TicWatches. It does manage to squeeze out a little bit more battery than the Apple Watch Series 10, based on my testing time.
The raw numbers state the Pixel Watch 3 can last up to 24 hours with the screen set to always-on, or you can switch to the Battery Saver mode to get up to 36 hours. The Apple Watch Series 10 lasts 18 hours, and really will if you keep the screen on at all times. Granted, it’s a pretty rapid charger, but it doesn’t negate that you definitely do end up having to think about the battery. Especially if you’re taking it to bed to track your sleep.
While the Pixel Watch 3 isn’t immune to similar concerns, it’s definitely slightly less of one compared to Apple’s smartwatch. Like Apple, it does try to remedy that with some pretty rapid charging support.
3. A very likeable round design
Apple’s smartwatch has remained square since the original Watch and seems unlikely to shift from that angular look. While there’s no shortage of round smartwatches, I’d say that the Pixel Watch 3’s round look stands out for the right reasons.
For starters, it comes in two different sizes, which is great news whether you like a smartwatch to dominate on the wrist or you prefer something that lives a little smaller, letting you strap on additional wristwear alongside it.
You’re getting a fully circular case design in either a polished or matte aluminium finish, an elegant watch crown, and a bright AMOLED display, and it has those deep black levels you associate with a high-quality colour screen. Combine all of that and you get something that’s sleek and really does set it apart from other smartwatches.
You certainly can’t accuse the Google Pixel Watch 3 of aping the look of the Apple Watch Series 10 or other Apple Watches, and while Apple also gets plenty of things right with its design, so does Google with its own.
What I disliked
1. The sports tracking
Apple beats Google when it comes to tracking your exercise. Quite simply, if you want a smartwatch that can closely match the performance of a dedicated sports watch, it’s not the Pixel Watch 3 you’ll want on your wrist.
Take GPS performance, or the fact that it doesn’t offer the latest dual-band GPS technology that now appears on a whole host of smartwatches, some of which cost less than the Pixel Watch 3.
If you look at the supported sports tracking profiles, there’s simply more on offer with Apple’s smartwatch. Take swimming as an example, where the Pixel Watch 3 only supports tracking pool swims, while Apple’s will track your movements in the open water and do a really good job of it.
If you’re heading outside to track workouts, Apple gives you maps to view. Some of that mapping is available out of the box, with a host of apps in the App Store that are capable of extending that to other sports.
That extensive third-party training and fitness app support gives Apple the upper hand to enhance its sports tracking capabilities. It also has the advantage of letting you pair external fitness accessories like a heart rate monitor, which you cannot do on the Pixel Watch 3.
Yes, there’s certainly enough on the Pixel Watch to track workouts and offer a satisfactory level of performance as well as a good array of metrics. The Apple Watch Series 10 is a much better performer across most, if not all, fronts.
2. The Fitbit Premium paywall
Having Fitbit take care of most of the Pixel Watch 3’s fitness and health tracking was a smart move, but you will need to shell out more money, either on a monthly or annual basis, to get the most complete Fitbit experience.
Thankfully, features like daily readiness scores, core activity tracking, and health metrics are available in the free version of the Fitbit App. The biggest features you’re going to miss out on by not paying up for Premium are the extra analysis offered for sleep and stress data. You also miss out on Fitbit’s workout videos and audio-based training sessions, but I’d say that richer sleep and stress insights are the things that most users will most appreciate having access to.
3. The battery life
Yes, I did like the fact that the Pixel Watch 3 (the larger 45mm version) has a better battery than the Apple Watch Series 10, but it’s not by a huge amount.
This is still a smartwatch where you have to think about the battery pretty much every day, whether the screen is on at all times, or when using the raise-to-wake gesture support. Having spent time with other Wear OS smartwatches that can go for almost a week without charging, it’s frustrating that Google didn’t seize the opportunity to make the Pixel Watch 3 go much longer than Apple’s Watches, or at least seek parity with the best WearOS battery performers.
4. No iPhone support
Now, this is exactly the same criticism that can be levelled at the Apple Watch and its inability to play nice with Android. This dislikable element of using a Pixel Watch is unlikely to change anytime soon. The lack of compatibility across the two biggest smartphone platforms instantly makes using the Google Pixel Watch 3 a restrictive experience for many.
If you don’t have the luxury to switch between Android phones and iPhones, then that’s going to be a pretty major reason to dislike the Pixel Watch 3.
Follow Tom’s Guide on Google News to get our up-to-date news, how-tos, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button.
