The 7 Best Face Masks for Sensitive Skin of 2025, Tested

Posted by

June 27, 2025

On June 27, 2025

As anyone with sensitive skin knows, trying new products can feel like a game of skincare roulette—just one application can be enough to spark a complexion crisis. But having easily irritated skin doesn’t mean you have to miss out on the buzziest new beauty formulas. It just might take extra vigilance when selecting the right one for you.

“Hydrating and anti-inflammatory masks that are fragrance-free and non-exfoliating are ideal for sensitive skin types,” says Claire O’Bryan, FNP-C, co-founder of Skin Clique. “Look for formulas labeled as ‘soothing’ or ‘calming,’ and avoid anything that claims to ‘purify’ or ‘detox’ as these often include harsher actives. The word “glow” can also mean exfoliating as well!” she adds.

We made it our mission to track down the best face masks for sensitive skin and put many of them to the test IRL. Our team of experts evaluated the formulas on active ingredients, texture, and overall results (especially how they made our skin feel immediately and over time). Ahead, find the best face masks that will improve the look and feel of skin without causing flare-ups.

Credit: Augustinus Bader

What We Like

Deeply hydrates
Boosts collagen production
Comes with a hypoallergenic Zamac applicator
Makes the skin plump and glowy

Key Ingredients: Vitamin C, ginseng extract, peptides, squalane | Size: 1.7 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Using Augustinus Bader’s The Face Cream Mask is a luxurious experience from start to finish. Loaded with natural amino acids, vitamins (including vitamin C), and peptides, the creamy yet lightweight mask deeply moisturizes the skin while also firming, brightening, and smoothing it. You can leave it to absorb for 10 minutes or let it sit overnight for extra nourishment. Our tester, who has sensitive skin, was a legitimate fan after using the formula for a month, noting that it quenched her dryness, eased her eczema flare-ups, and never once caused irritation. She also appreciated that it comes with a hypoallergenic Zamac applicator, which cools and de-puffs your complexion on contact and prevents bacterial contamination.

Byrdie

Adi Giesey, editor with sensitive skin: “This face mask is a staple in my routine. It’s the perfect extra step when you want to hydrate and brighten your skin without the fuss.”

LANEIGE Hypoallergenic Cica Sleeping Mask

Credit: Sephora

What We Like

Soothes red and irritated skin
Strengthens moisture barrier
Heals flakes and dry patches

Key Ingredients: Squalane, panthenol, centella, tea tree oil | Size: 2 oz | Cruelty-Free: No

When your skin is feeling irritated and sensitized, reach for this hypoallergenic overnight mask. Its blend of actives, including centella asiatica (a powerful anti-inflammatory) and hydrating squalane, works while you sleep, leaving you with a calmer complexion by morning. Our tester, who has been using this mask for years, loves how quickly the soft, creamy texture melts into her skin, leaving it noticeably softer, smoother, and free from any redness or irritation. It’s also designed to fortify the skin barrier, helping prevent future flare-ups from occurring.

Byrdie

Alyssa Kaplan, editor with combination skin: “This formula is super soft and soothing. The next morning, my skin looks calm, and it feels nourished and irritation-free.”

Credit: Bloomingdale’s

Ingredients: Charcoal powder, argan oil, shea butter | Skin Type: All | Size: 1 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Do you want pore-deep purification, but you’ve got finicky skin? Reach for this gentle yet effective charcoal-infused mask. The charcoal helps draw dirt and excess sebum from your pores, while argan oil and shea butter work to restore moisture, preventing the stripped feeling that’s not ideal for sensitive complexions. The mask also contains rose water, known for its soothing properties. Our tester, who has sensitive skin, loved how comfortable and hydrated her face felt after using it.

Byrdie

Samantha, tester with combination skin: “I like that this product kept its promise to be gentle on my skin. My skin can be quite sensitive, and although I know that charcoal is a powerful detoxifier, it didn’t dehydrate my skin.”

Glow Recipe Watermelon Glow Hyaluronic Clay Pore-Tight Facial Mask

Credit: Sephora

Ingredients: Kaolin clay, hyaluronic acid, watermelon enzymes, beta-hydroxy acids, blueberry seed powder | Size: 2 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

If you’ve already written off clay masks as too harsh for your skin, think again. This non-drying formula from Glow Recipe contains hyaluronic acid-infused kaolin clay to hydrate pores as it purifies them. It also features BHAs (chemical exfoliants, gentle enough for sensitive skin) and microbeads of blueberry seed powder to help slough off dead and dull cells without upsetting your skin barrier. The mask takes just five minutes to work, and our tester was amazed by how bright, fresh, bouncy, and clean it left her sensitive skin.

Byrdie

Mariah, tester with combination skin: “After removing, my skin looked brighter than usual and almost dewier than I would’ve expected with a clay mask. It was also very soft.”

Credit: Sephora

Key Ingredients: Solomon’s seal powder, ginseng root extract, glycerin | Size: 4.05 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

If the complexion of your dreams is as clear and smooth as it is calm and resilient, try this peel-off mask from Korean beauty brand Sulwhasoo. The formula (which contains antioxidant-rich ginseng and brightening Solomon’s seal powder) goes on thick and sticky like honey but feels cool and refreshing on the skin. Once dry, you delicately peel off the formula, and the dirt and debris from your pores is removed with it. Our tester noticed that her blackheads were diminished and her pores were less noticeable after around five uses. The result was smooth and glowy, with no noticeable irritation—a big plus for her sensitive skin.

Byrdie

Ashley, tester with dry/sensitive skin: “I loved the visible difference that was apparent after building this product into my routine. My pores look lighter and smaller, and overall, it added a glow to my skin that radiates.”

Credit: Amazon

What We Like

Calms and cools skin quickly
Hydrates and reduces redness
Approved for post-procedure sensitivity

Key Ingredients: Hyaluronic acid, dipeptide, and botanicals (cucumber, thyme, and olive extracts) | Size: 2 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

If your skin is freaking out and you need a solution fast, reach for the SkinCeuticals Phyto Corrective Mask. The formula contains hydrating hyaluronic acid, a soothing blend of botanicals including cooling cucumber extract, and dipeptide, a soothing molecule that helps reduce heat sensitivity. A fan favorite among individuals with sensitive skin, as well as those recovering from procedures such as IPL and laser resurfacing treatments, it promises to calm and cool the complexion, quickly eliminating redness and irritation.

First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Instant Oatmeal Mask

Credit: Amazon

What We Like

Hydrates and nourishes
Soothes and softens sensitive skin
Helps protect the skin barrier
Reduces redness and irritation

Key Ingredients: Colloidal oatmeal, shea butter, bisabolol, sea buckthorn | Size: 2 oz | Cruelty-Free: Yes

If your skin is dry and sensitive, this ultra-hydrating mask might be perfect for you. The thick, nourishing formula calls on soothing colloidal oatmeal (a go-to for eczema-prone skin) and bisabolol (one of the active parts of chamomile), moisturizing shea butter, and antioxidant-rich sea buckthorn. It’s specifically designed with sensitive skin in mind, helping to keep redness, irritation, and dryness in check when used two-to-three times a week. A heads up though: If your skin is on the oilier side, this option might be a little too heavy and moisturizing for you.

What to Look for in a Face Mask for Sensitive Skin

Gentle Ingredients: The goal of any effective sensitive skin routine is to achieve noticeable results without irritation, which can involve a bit of trial and error. O’Bryan recommends looking for products featuring gentle, hydrating ingredients like niacinamide, ceramides, or colloidal oatmeal, which will help calm your skin and support your skin barrier with each application.
Nourishing Formulas: “Cream or gel formulas are typically more soothing than clay or peel-off types,” explains O’Bryan. Creams, in particular, have a thicker, more luxurious texture that helps retain moisture. That being said, clay formulas and peel-offs aren’t out of the question so long as they contain ingredients that add plenty of hydration to counteract any possible stripping effects.
Container Types: The best container for a sensitive skin face mask is an airless pump bottle or tube, both of which maintain the product’s integrity, minimize contamination, and don’t introduce irritants that might cause a flare-up. If your mask is in a jar, take care to use clean hands or a hygienic spatula when applying.

FAQ

The list of possible sensitive skin irritants is long and varies from person to person, but as a general rule, says O’Bryan, “avoid alcohol, fragrance, essential oils, menthol, and strong exfoliants like glycolic acid, as these can all trigger an inflammatory reaction.”

It’s good to read the manufacturer’s instructions, but you should see them as a suggestion rather than a rule. Go slow and monitor your skin’s reaction. O’Bryan even suggests doing a patch test first. “Sensitive skin thrives with consistency and gentle support, not overstimulation,” she explains.

As a consumer, it can be hard to separate truth from marketing hype, especially because labels are not consistently regulated. “Fragrance-free can be a good starting point,” says O’Bryan, “and some masks or products are actually approved by the National Rosacea Foundation.” Always review the ingredient list, and if in doubt, consult a board-certified skincare provider for personalized advice, O’Bryan advises.

Meet Our Expert

To ensure we selected the very best face masks for sensitive skin, we spoke with the following experts:

Claire O’Bryan, FNP-C, is the co-founder of Skin Clique and a board-certified nurse practitioner who specializes in treating sensitive skin and helping patients build effective, personalized skincare routines.

Why Trust Byrdie

Esme Benjamin is a Brooklyn-based freelance journalist who writes about beauty and wellness for the country’s top publications. She’s contributed to Byrdie since 2023 and loves uncovering the best products and recommendations. Her skin skews sensitive, so she’s always on the lookout for gentle, reliable products like these masks.